Lesson 7: Evolution of Canada’s Immigration Policy

1. Introduction

Immigration has always played a key role in shaping Canada's identity. From the early days of European settlers to the arrival of people from all over the world, Canada's story is one of continuous change and growth through immigration. As Canada has evolved, so too have its immigration policies. These policies have determined who could enter the country and under what circumstances. They have shaped the country's diversity, economy, and society.

In the early years after Confederation, Canada’s immigration policies focused primarily on attracting European settlers to populate and farm the land, particularly in Western Canada. The government offered incentives like free land, hoping to expand its territory and boost the agricultural economy. At the same time, restrictive measures, such as the Chinese Immigration Act, were put in place to control who could come into the country. These laws favored certain groups over others, often based on race or nationality.

As global events like the world wars and the Great Depression unfolded, Canada’s immigration policies became more restrictive, limiting the number of people allowed to enter, especially those fleeing persecution or seeking refuge. But by the 1960s, the government made significant changes, introducing policies that aimed to attract skilled workers and professional talent, regardless of their country of origin. This shift laid the foundation for the more inclusive system we see today.

This lesson will explore the evolution of these policies, from the early days of settler colonialism to the modern points-based system. We will also examine the impact of these changes on Canadian society—how they have influenced population growth, economic development, and cultural diversity. Understanding how these policies evolved helps us appreciate Canada’s journey toward becoming one of the most multicultural nations in the world, a place where people from all corners of the globe can contribute and thrive.

2. Historical Overview (1867-1945)

Canada’s immigration policies during the late 19th and early 20th centuries were shaped by the country’s desire to grow and develop economically. The government’s main goal was to attract European settlers to populate the land, especially in Western Canada. However, these policies were not fair to everyone. While they encouraged some groups to settle, others faced discrimination and restrictions.

Early Policies (1867-1914)

After Canada became a country in 1867, the government needed to encourage people to settle its vast lands, especially in the prairies. To do this, it introduced policies that favored European immigrants. One of the most significant was the Dominion Lands Act of 1872, which offered free land to settlers willing to farm. This attracted large numbers of immigrants from Britain, Ireland, and other parts of Europe, including places like Ukraine and Germany. These new settlers played a key role in developing Canada’s agricultural industry, particularly in provinces like Manitoba and Saskatchewan.

However, not everyone was welcomed equally. Chinese immigrants, who were brought to Canada to help build the Canadian Pacific Railway (completed in 1885), faced harsh treatment and discrimination. In 1885, the Canadian government passed the Chinese Immigration Act, which imposed a “head tax” on Chinese immigrants. This tax was meant to discourage them from coming to Canada. The amount of the tax increased over the years, making it nearly impossible for many Chinese families to bring over their relatives. This is an example of how Canada's early immigration policies were often based on race and sought to limit the entry of certain groups.

World War I and Post-War Restrictions (1915-1930s)

As World War I (1914-1918) began, immigration to Canada slowed down significantly. The war caused economic and political instability, and the government was more focused on the war effort than on bringing new immigrants. During this time, immigration became more selective. People from enemy nations, such as Germany and Austria-Hungary, were no longer allowed to immigrate to Canada, and some immigrants from these countries who were already in Canada were sent to internment camps.

After World War I ended, there was a brief period when immigration increased again. Many soldiers returned to Canada, and there was a push to bring in more immigrants to help rebuild the economy. However, this did not last long. The Great Depression in the 1930s caused widespread poverty and unemployment. As a result, Canada significantly reduced the number of immigrants it accepted, fearing that newcomers would compete with Canadians for jobs.

During this time, many people who desperately needed refuge were turned away. One of the most notable cases was the MS St. Louis, a ship carrying over 900 Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi persecution in 1939. The ship was denied entry to Canada and other countries, forcing the refugees to return to Europe, where many of them later died in the Holocaust. This tragic event revealed the harsh reality of Canada’s restrictive immigration policies during this period, particularly toward refugees.

World War II (1939-1945)

When World War II began, Canada again limited immigration, focusing its efforts on the war. However, as the war came to an end, the country faced new challenges. Millions of people in Europe had been displaced by the war, and many were looking for new places to settle. Although Canada initially restricted immigration during the war, this period set the stage for major changes that would come after 1945, leading to more open and inclusive policies in the following decades.

3. Post-WWII Shifts (1946-1980)

After World War II, Canada’s immigration policies shifted significantly. The war had displaced millions of people across Europe, and Canada began to open its doors to more diverse groups of immigrants. This period marked a turning point in the country’s approach to immigration, as the government recognized the need for skilled workers to help rebuild the economy, and society became more open to accepting people from different backgrounds.

Post-War Immigration Boom (1946-1960s)

In the years immediately following World War II, Canada began accepting large numbers of refugees and displaced persons from war-torn Europe. These included people from countries like Italy, Greece, and Poland, who had been devastated by the war. The Canadian government recognized the need to bring in workers to fill labor shortages, particularly in industries like construction, manufacturing, and mining. This wave of immigrants played a key role in rebuilding Canada’s economy and helping it recover from the effects of the war.

One major change during this time was the growing focus on family reunification. Many people who had immigrated to Canada before the war were now able to bring over their families. This policy helped strengthen immigrant communities and allowed newcomers to settle more easily, as they had the support of their loved ones. Family reunification became an important part of Canada’s immigration policy, recognizing the social and emotional benefits of keeping families together.

At the same time, Canada’s immigration policies still favored certain groups over others. Most of the immigrants accepted during this period were from Europe, as the government preferred to bring in people they believed would integrate easily into Canadian society. This meant that immigrants from non-European countries continued to face significant barriers. However, this was about to change.

The Immigration Act of 1952

The Immigration Act of 1952 was a key piece of legislation that helped shape Canada’s post-war immigration policy. While it still gave the government the power to exclude certain people based on their race or nationality, it also laid the groundwork for future reforms. The act introduced measures to attract skilled workers, marking the beginning of a shift toward selecting immigrants based on their ability to contribute to the economy, rather than their country of origin.

Though the 1952 Act was not perfect and still contained discriminatory elements, it showed that Canada was slowly moving toward a more inclusive system. By the late 1950s, the government began to rethink its approach to immigration, leading to the most significant change in 1967.

The Points System (1967)

The most dramatic change in Canada’s immigration policy came with the introduction of the Points System in 1967. This system transformed how immigrants were selected, moving away from racial or ethnic preferences and focusing instead on factors like skills, education, language ability, and work experience. The Points System awarded potential immigrants points based on these criteria, and those with the highest scores were given priority for entry into Canada.

The introduction of the Points System was revolutionary because it ended racial discrimination in immigration policy. Instead of being judged by their country of origin, immigrants were now assessed based on their potential to contribute to the Canadian economy. This opened the door for people from a wider range of countries, including those from Asia, Africa, and the Caribbean, who had previously been excluded.

As a result, Canada became a more diverse and multicultural society. Immigrants from all over the world began to come to Canada, bringing with them new cultures, traditions, and ideas. This shift laid the foundation for modern Canada’s multicultural identity, which would later be reinforced by the Canadian Multiculturalism Act of 1988.

The period from 1946 to 1980 was a time of significant change in Canada’s immigration policies. From welcoming refugees after World War II to introducing the Points System, Canada’s approach to immigration became more inclusive and focused on economic contribution. These changes set the stage for the multicultural society that Canada is known for today.

4. Modern Era Policies (1980-Present)

As Canada moved into the 1980s, its immigration policies continued to evolve, reflecting the changing needs of the country and its growing multicultural identity. During this period, several important policies and programs were introduced that shaped modern immigration, focusing on inclusion, economic growth, and humanitarian efforts.

The Canadian Multiculturalism Act (1988)

In 1988, the Canadian government passed the Canadian Multiculturalism Act, which officially recognized and celebrated Canada’s diversity. This act aimed to protect and promote the cultural heritage of all Canadians, regardless of their background, while encouraging full participation in society. It was a groundbreaking piece of legislation that made Canada one of the first countries in the world to adopt an official policy of multiculturalism.

The Multiculturalism Act was significant for immigration because it reinforced the idea that newcomers to Canada were not expected to abandon their cultural identities. Instead, they were encouraged to celebrate and share their traditions while becoming part of Canadian society. This helped foster a sense of belonging among immigrants and made Canada an attractive destination for people from all over the world.

By promoting inclusivity and diversity, the Multiculturalism Act built on the foundations laid by the Points System of 1967. Together, these policies helped shape Canada into a country where immigrants were seen as vital contributors to the nation’s cultural richness and economic success.

Changes in the 1990s and Early 2000s

During the 1990s, Canada introduced several programs to address its economic and labor needs. One of the key focuses was on skilled immigration. The government developed systems that made it easier for skilled workers to immigrate, as the country recognized the need for professionals in fields like healthcare, technology, and engineering. Programs were expanded to recruit these workers, ensuring that Canada remained competitive in a global economy.

At the same time, Canada continued to welcome immigrants under family reunification programs, which allowed citizens and permanent residents to sponsor close family members. This policy remained an essential part of Canada’s immigration system, emphasizing the social and emotional importance of keeping families together.

Canada also remained committed to its role as a safe haven for refugees. In 1999, for example, Canada accepted thousands of Kosovar refugees fleeing conflict in the former Yugoslavia. Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, Canada worked closely with the United Nations to identify and resettle refugees from conflict zones around the world, further strengthening its global reputation as a leader in humanitarian efforts.

21st Century Policies: Express Entry and Provincial Nominee Programs

In the 21st century, Canada’s immigration system continued to adapt to the country’s economic and social needs. In 2015, the government introduced the Express Entry system, which is a faster and more efficient way to select skilled immigrants. Express Entry ranks applicants based on their skills, education, work experience, and language abilities. Those with the highest scores are invited to apply for permanent residency. This system ensures that Canada can quickly attract the workers it needs to fill labor shortages in key sectors like technology, healthcare, and construction.

In addition to Express Entry, the Provincial Nominee Program (PNP) became increasingly popular. This program allows provinces and territories to nominate individuals who meet their specific labor market needs. For example, a province like Saskatchewan might prioritize immigrants with agricultural skills, while a province like British Columbia could focus on technology professionals. This program allows for flexibility, ensuring that immigrants are placed in regions where their skills are most needed.

Canada’s Response to Global Crises

In recent years, Canada has continued to show leadership in responding to global humanitarian crises. In 2015, the country made headlines when it welcomed over 25,000 Syrian refugees who were fleeing the Syrian Civil War. This move demonstrated Canada’s commitment to providing a safe refuge for those in need, even as debates over immigration and refugees intensified globally. The Canadian government, alongside private sponsors, helped resettle these refugees, providing housing, language training, and support for integration into Canadian society.

However, modern immigration policies have not been without challenges. There has been ongoing debate about balancing Canada’s economic needs with its humanitarian commitments. Additionally, issues such as immigration fraud and the strain on urban infrastructure, particularly in cities like Toronto and Vancouver, have prompted discussions about how to manage immigration effectively while ensuring that newcomers have access to necessary services.

5. Impact on Society (Cultural, Economic, Social)

Canada’s evolving immigration policies have had a profound impact on the country’s society, shaping its culture, economy, and social fabric. As immigration policies shifted over time to become more inclusive, the contributions of immigrants have enriched the country in multiple ways.

Cultural Impact

One of the most visible effects of Canada’s immigration policies is the development of a multicultural society. With people coming from all over the world, Canada has become a mosaic of cultures, languages, and traditions. Immigrants have brought with them their customs, music, festivals, and foods, which have been embraced and celebrated across the country. Cities like Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal are known for their diversity, where communities from different cultures live side by side.

Events such as Toronto’s Caribbean Carnival, Vancouver’s Lunar New Year celebrations, and Edmonton’s Heritage Festival showcase the cultural richness that immigration has brought to Canada. These festivals and traditions are not just enjoyed by immigrant communities but are also celebrated by Canadians of all backgrounds. This has led to a deeper understanding and appreciation of different cultures, helping foster a more inclusive society.

Economic Impact

Immigrants have played a critical role in boosting Canada’s economy. As Canada’s population ages, immigrants help fill important gaps in the workforce. Programs like the Points System and Express Entry focus on bringing in skilled workers, who contribute to industries like healthcare, technology, and engineering. These workers help meet the country’s labor demands, ensuring economic growth and innovation.

In addition to skilled workers, immigrants also contribute as entrepreneurs. Many immigrants start small businesses, creating jobs and contributing to local economies. Research shows that immigrants are more likely to start businesses compared to native-born Canadians. This entrepreneurial spirit has helped strengthen Canada’s economy and made it more dynamic.

Social Impact

Immigration has also had a significant social impact on Canada, both in terms of challenges and successes. On one hand, immigration has enriched Canadian communities by introducing new perspectives and fostering a spirit of inclusivity. However, it has also presented challenges. Immigrants often face barriers when trying to integrate into society, such as language difficulties, finding employment that matches their skills, and navigating social services.

To help address these issues, the Canadian government has introduced programs aimed at supporting newcomers, such as language training and settlement services. These initiatives help immigrants adapt more easily, ensuring that they can contribute fully to society.

9. Videos